Evaluating your Network needs and
choosing the right Technology for your Network applications.
Why some End Users make the choice for
Endspan Switching w/ PoE
Here are some of the reasons why many End Users ultimately choose
PoE enabled Endspan Switches for their Networks:
- There are no existing Ethernet Switches in place, or older
Ethernet switches in place, buying new Ethernet Switches
anyway (possibly for new construction)
- PoE required for End devices is all one type (generally
IEEE 802.3af
or legacy Cisco CDP style) and the installation has a large
Port count
- Limited space in 19" racks to mount Midspan units
(more of an issue in large scale implementations) where
IP nodes are in the high hundreds or thousands
- Budget available to spend more on powered Switch PoE implementation
- Does not like or want the extra patch cords involved with
connecting an Ethernet Switch to a Midspan PoE Hub
- View Midspan and Switch together as two separate potential
points of failure
- Have been subjected to pressure from Ethernet Switch Manufacturer
to not induce any other Network products into the network
- Corporate mandate for all Network devices to have an IP
address
- Consultant or Systems Integrator has specified Endspan
technology
- Do not need full power (15.4 watts) per Port, application
OK with limited power per Port. Most Endspan PoE units develop
only 200 watts total per 24 Ports or an average 8.3 watts
per Port. This will work for powering most IP Phones but
is not enough power for many other Network devices
- End User views this as "easy way" to implement
PoE, somehow requiring
less work than an installation using Midspan Hubs
Here's why other End Users make the
choice for a Midspan PoE Hub
These are some of the reasons why other End Users ultimately
choose Midspan PoE Hubs or Injectors for their Networks:
- Have new or newer existing Ethernet switches in place,
buying new Ethernet Switches just to get the PoE function
would be a waste of resources both in the actual dollars
for purchase and the man hours of set-up time to customize
the Switch for End User's network
- PoE required for the End devices is of mixed types because
of different requirements for different brands and models
of powered End devices
- No limitation on rack space to mount the actual Midspan
PoE hubs
- Lower Budget, overall dollars spent are far less with
Midspan PoE implementation compared to purchase of powered
Switches
- Is fine with patch cord connectivity between Switch and
Midspan Hub
- Consultant or Systems Integrator has specified Midspan
technology
- View PoE enabled Switch as a single point of failure and
want to separate the two functions so that repairability
is maintained should one function or the other experience
failure
- Not subject to pressure from Switch Manufacturer against
introduction of other products into the Network
- End User views this as "easy way" to implement
PoE, requiring less work than implementing new Switches
with all of their programming and set-up
In addition, here are some unique
additional reasons why many End Users choose LAN Power Systems
Midspan PoE Hubs
- Want modularity by Multi Port module to lessen impact
of power incident or be able to add support for more End
device Port connections in the future
- Want Hot-swap ability of Multi Port modules in and out
of chassis
- Want built in support from day one for Gigabit Ethernet
speeds as well as Ethernet and Fast Ethernet data transmission
speeds
- Want options for Higher Power modules, up to 36 watts
per Port on all Ports simultaneously if necessary for emerging
End devices
- Want ability to intermix module styles within a single
chassis to support different PoE requirements from single
wiring closet
- Want options for non-standard voltages like 24v, 12v and
5v End devices
- The User's application demands full power per Port at
all times on all module Ports simultaneously.
- Want the simplicity of Full Power per Port to eliminate
required "Power Management" Software found on
both Endspan and most other Midspans
- Want Single Port Power Injectors to support a single End
device if needed
- Want 8 Port workgroup Power hubs to support small groups
of End devices
- Want hot swapability by multi Port module in case of a
power fault condition, do not want to remove PoE hub or
powered switch and ship somewhere for repair, want to do
repair in short amount of time on-site or in-house
- Want a longer warranty period. LAN Power products come
with full 2 year warranty included vs. most Endspan products
come with warranties ranging from 90 days to 1 year.
Conclusion
The marketplace for both Endspan and Midspan PoE is healthy
and will continue to grow in future years. This growth is
based partly on a wide range of additional new products coming
which will be powerable via PoE technology. Many of these
devices will be better suited to Midspan powering due to variances
in voltage or wattage requirements or the smaller number of
units required on the End User's Network. LAN Power Systems,
as a major technology innovator in the PoE market, is committed
to long-term participation and continual development of new
Midspan PoE products which incorporate the key elements of
Flexibility, Simplicity and Value.
|